TAHIR AMIN & NUZHAT NAZAR

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan cannot achieve sustainable economic growth without a sustained increase in exports, improved access to finance for small and medium enterprises (SMEs), devolution of powers, and a comprehensive review of the National Finance Commission (NFC) Award, said Minister of State for Finance Bilal Azhar Kayani.

Advisor to the Prime Minister and Chairman of the Privatisation Commission Muhammad Ali disclosed that all prospective investors interested in acquiring electricity distribution companies (DISCOs) had expressed willingness to take 100 percent ownership of the entities.

Addressing the 6th Pakistan Prosperity Forum, organised by the Policy Research Institute of Market Economy (PRIME) under the theme “Growth in a Region of Crisis”, the two government ministers stressed the need for far-reaching structural reforms, greater private-sector participation and policy consistency to put the economy on a sustainable growth trajectory.

Kayani said macroeconomic stability was merely the foundation for sustainable and inclusive economic growth, which required stronger exports, private-sector investment and improved governance. He said Pakistan needed an economy in which foreign exchange reserves increased through production and exports rather than consumption-driven growth.

He outlined several measures taken by the government to reduce the cost of doing business and support exporters, including abolishing the 0.25 percent Export Development Surcharge and transferring control of the Export Development Fund (EDF) to exporters, with the private sector holding a majority on its board.

The government had also eliminated super tax for businesses earning between Rs150 million and Rs500 million and reduced the rate from 10 percent to 8 percent for those earning above Rs500 million. The combined advance and minimum tax burden on exporters had been reduced from 2 percent to 1.25 percent, while the 0.25 percent final tax regime on IT exports had been extended for another three years.

He said the Export Finance Scheme (EFS) financing envelope had been increased by 50 percent to Rs1.5 trillion from Rs1 trillion, with Rs300 billion earmarked exclusively for SMEs. The government had also introduced a Rs300 billion long-term export financing facility, offering financing at 2 percent for the first three years and 5 percent for the subsequent eight years. Another Rs50 billion could be earmarked for SMEs from the long-term financing envelope, he added.

The minister identified access to finance as the foremost challenge facing SMEs, saying the government was engaging banks to improve lending to smaller businesses, farmers and low-cost housing.

However, he stressed that sustainable prosperity could not be achieved through macroeconomic measures alone, calling for decentralisation, stronger local governments, civil service reforms and a serious review of the NFC formula to address fiscal disparities between the federation and provinces. Kayani said sustainable economic growth required simultaneous progress on exports, private-sector investment, institutional reforms, decentralisation and the quality of public services.

Muhammad Ali said around 10 investors were examining opportunities in Islamabad, Gujranwala and Faisalabad DISCOs, with seven local consortia comprising two to four investors. These were expected to consolidate into five to six bidders, creating healthy competition for the three transactions.

He said the government had initially offered stakes ranging from 51 to 100 percent, but investors preferred complete ownership. Ali said the government was also preparing a fundamental restructuring of the electricity market, moving away from the existing single-buyer arrangement towards a competitive model under which consumers would have greater choice of electricity suppliers.

Under the proposed framework, distribution networks would remain regulated monopolies, while private-sector suppliers would purchase electricity from different sources and sell it to consumers. The Privatisation Commission had prepared a reform paper, shared with prospective investors and the Power Division, which was expected to be made public next week, he added.

Under the proposed framework, Pakistan would move towards an electricity market based on international models, including those of Türkiye and the United Kingdom, allowing consumers greater choice of suppliers.

He said although the legal separation of electricity supply and distribution businesses already existed, it had not been implemented in practice.

The proposed arrangement envisages the electricity distribution network, or wires business, remaining a regulated monopoly, while electricity suppliers would operate competitively in the private sector, purchasing power from different sources and selling it to consumers.

“This is the only way we will bring efficiency into the power sector,” he said, adding that acceptance of the proposed reforms could fundamentally transform the electricity market.

He said Pakistan’s power sector faced challenges different from those encountered by countries such as the UK when they undertook electricity-sector privatisation, including excess generation capacity, relatively weak GDP growth, limited demand growth and rapid changes in renewable energy and battery technologies.

He said the privatisation programme covered nine DISCOs, with Islamabad, Gujranwala and Faisalabad at advanced stages, followed by Hyderabad and Sukkur and subsequently Lahore, Multan, Peshawar and Quetta.

He cautioned that privatisation alone would not resolve the power sector’s problems without competition and stronger regulation by the National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (NEPRA). He said the government was not convinced that a golden share arrangement was necessary, arguing that strengthening NEPRA would be more appropriate.

High electricity prices were undermining industrialisation, export competitiveness and employment generation, he said, adding that the proposed restructuring was aimed at improving efficiency rather than merely transferring public assets into private hands. Ali emphasised the need for clarity, cooperation and consistency in government policies to attract private investment and accelerate economic transformation.

He said state-owned enterprises (SOEs) had reported aggregate losses of Rs342 billion during the first half of FY26, while government support to these entities increased 31 percent to Rs804 billion compared with the corresponding period of the previous year. He said the government needed to reconsider its role in operating commercial enterprises where the private sector could deliver services more efficiently.

On the Pakistan International Airlines (PIA) transaction, he said the first closing involved Rs90 billion, of which Rs80 billion would be invested in the airline and Rs10 billion would go to the government. A further Rs90 billion would be received at the second closing, divided equally between the airline and the government.

He also highlighted the potential of public-private partnerships, saying two sections of the Hyderabad-Sukkur M-6 motorway had been approved under the PPP model, involving an estimated investment of USD672 million. The government would provide USD156 million in viability gap funding, while the private sector would design, build, finance, maintain and operate the motorway under a 25-year concession.

Ali said frequent policy reversals and interventions undermined investor confidence and discouraged long-term investment, emphasising that commercial risks should be borne by private investors rather than transferred to taxpayers through government guarantees and bailouts.

He also called for greater attention to digitalisation alongside tax and electricity-sector reforms, arguing that digital tools could accelerate broader economic and governance reforms.

Louie Dane, Senior Economic Adviser at the British High Commission in Islamabad, said Pakistan’s economic growth would remain constrained unless it substantially increased exports and foreign exchange earnings.

“Pakistan’s growth will only last if it earns and sells more to the world,” he said, adding that the country’s recurring balance-of-payments crises reflected its inability to generate sufficient foreign exchange to finance economic expansion.

Citing Asian Development Bank research, he said Pakistan could sustain economic growth of only around 3.8 percent before imports outpaced exports and external pressures intensified.

He identified five priority areas for supporting Pakistan’s export-led growth: regulatory reforms, trade facilitation, trade promotion, skills development and easing foreign exchange restrictions.

He identified IT and IT-enabled services, pharmaceuticals, engineering goods, and manufactured food and beverages as sectors with significant export potential.

Dane said Pakistan needed to align regulations and quality infrastructure with international standards, pointing out that although Sialkot manufactured world-class surgical instruments, no Pakistani laboratory was accredited to test products against European Union medical-device regulations.

He also called for improvements in customs procedures, export documentation, integration of export processes into the Pakistan Single Window and timely processing of letters of credit.

On trade promotion, he said Pakistani surgical instruments were frequently sold without domestic branding through foreign intermediaries, allowing other countries to capture much of the value.

He welcomed the government’s initiative to modernise the Trade Development Authority of Pakistan (TDAP), stressing the need for merit-based recruitment, measurable targets and independent performance evaluation.

Highlighting the skills gap, he said that despite growth in IT exports, leading companies estimated that only one in 10 IT graduates was employable upon completing education.

He also called for easier access to foreign exchange to enable exporters to meet overseas registration, certification, regulatory compliance and marketing expenses.

Supply-side economist RizwanRawji called for lower tax rates on a broader tax base, spending restraint and privatisation to improve economic competitiveness.

Mohammed A. Rajpar, Managing Director of General Shipping Agencies (Pvt) Ltd, said disruption in the Strait of Hormuz had exposed spare capacity at Pakistan’s ports. Gwadar had received more cargo and ships during the three months following the conflict than in the preceding three years, he added.

Dr Ali Salman, Chief Executive Officer of PRIME, proposed five major economic governance reforms that he said Pakistan could implement without relying on foreign loans for technical assistance.

These included replacing the Planning Commission with a Growth and Reforms Commission, reducing the General Sales Tax (GST) rate to 5 percent across the board without exemptions, offering federal secretaries three-year contracts with salaries at least three times their existing pay, harmonising business regulations across provinces and abolishing the Economic Coordination Committee.