FCC releases detailed verdict on provincial infrastructure cess
TERENCE J SIGAMONY
ISLAMABAD: The Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) on Friday issued its detailed verdict on petitions challenging the infrastructure cess in Sindh and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, ruling that a provincial levy does not become invalid merely because it affects imported goods; equally, a charge that is, in substance, a customs impost and does not fall within provincial competence merely because its proceeds finance provincial infrastructure.
A two-judge bench comprising Chief Justice Amin-ud-Din Khan and Justice Aamir Farooq set aside the judgments of the Sindh High Court and Peshawar High Court, which upheld the infrastructure cess imposed by the provincial governments of Sindh and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa.
The FCC’s 60-page judgment, authored by Chief Justice Amin, said the impugned judgments gave controlling weight to the infrastructure purpose, movement of goods, and asserted the compensatory character of the cess without first establishing provincial legislative competence. None supplies an independent provincial basis for the challenged import, export and external transit charges. The federation’s submission is accepted to that extent because it accords with the constitutional allocation of power; federal concurrence is not itself determinative.
It noted that the impugned judgments proceed upon an erroneous construction of the respective enactments by treating the stated infrastructure purpose and asserted compensatory character of the cess as determinative of its constitutional validity. The proper inquiry concerns the statutory event attracting liability and the levy’s true nature and operation.
The challenged charging provisions attach liability to the import, export or transit of goods; references to infrastructure, road carriage or distance do not, by themselves, establish an independent provincial basis for the charge. The High Courts thus confused the purpose for which the proceeds were to be applied with the subject upon which the levy was imposed, and consequently failed to give effect to the constitutional limits upon provincial legislative competence.
The FCC said that the corresponding charging provisions and all dependent rules, notifications, assessments and recovery measures are declared to be unconstitutional and without lawful authority. No demand, surcharge or penalty founded solely upon those charges shall be enforced. Securities furnished solely for the invalid charges shall be discharged upon verification and subject to any subsisting order governing their disposal. The Provinces remain free to enact constitutionally competent infrastructure or service charges on goods manufactured and consumed within the province.
Regarding Section 14 of the KP Finance Act, 2024, which substituted section 3(1) of the Act 2022, the judgment noted that extending the enactment to domestic goods cannot validate a distinct charge whose essential subject remains within the federal legislative field. Mere transit through a Province neither exempts goods from competent local laws nor authorises an ad valorem charge solely upon their passage. The challenged levy rests upon the consignment’s international or interprovincial movement, without an independently identified local service to sustain it. A province cannot create a fiscal barrier within the national trading system merely by describing the charge as compensation for infrastructure. It noted that a province cannot create a fiscal barrier within the national trading system merely by describing the charge as compensation for infrastructure.
The judgment said that Article 144 provides no reciprocal mechanism for transferring Parliament’s exclusive taxing power to a Province through executive arrangements. Article 143 of the Constitution and the federal statutory framework do not alter that conclusion. Parliament’s decision not to exercise a fiscal power does not transfer that subject to the provinces.
It held that Article 160 of the Constitution and the applicable National Finance Commission arrangements distinguish the power to levy a federal tax from entitlement to its proceeds. A province’s share does not authorise it to impose that tax independently. Equally, two competent levies are not unconstitutional merely because they affect the same goods. The defect here is legislative incompetence, not duplication; fiscal need cannot supply the missing power.
The judgment said that the delegated legislation can neither exceed the parent enactment nor supply legislative competence; its validity otherwise depends upon the enabling provision and constitutional limits. Rules, notifications and recovery measures founded upon the unconstitutional charge consequently fall to that extent.
References to movement or infrastructure maintenance cannot sustain a charge whose essential operation falls within the exclusive federal field.
The use of federal customs officers concerns administration, not legislative competence. Article 147 of the Constitution permits entrustment of provincial functions to the Federal Government or its officers with federal consent and the prescribed provincial ratification.